I saw this on the Carpetblogger’s tweeter account:

imageOSUBunny1” is the Twitter account of Matt Borges.

Matt Borges was former Republican Ohio Treasurer “Dirty” Joe Deters’ chief-of-staff.  In 2004, Borges pled guilty to a misdemeanor count of improper use of a public office, and was fined $1,000 (Cincinnati Enquirer):

Borges, 32, of Columbus pleaded guilty to one count of improper use of public office, a misdemeanor, and was fined $1,000 by Cuyahoga County Common Pleas Judge Eileen Gallagher. Court documents said he gave preferential treatment to certain brokers who made contributions to Deters’ re-election campaign.

SG Cowen Corp. and Lehman Brothers Inc. hired Gruttadauria, and from 1999 to 2001 they did a combined $5.9 billion in investment trades with Deters’ office.

"If one reads what (Borges) admitted doing, he used the power of his office to gain favorable treatment for vendors that did business with the office," Sammon said.

"To me, that’s a very serious offense."

In short, Borges steered state investment business to convicted swindlers like former Cuyahoga Lehman Brothers broker Frank Gruttadauria (who stolen millions from his clients) and other companies, like Lehman Brothers, in return for steering donations earmarked for the Deters campaign through the Hamilton County Republican Party in order to avoid maximum campaign donor limits.  According to the Plain Dealer at the time:

“If Ohioans’ tax dollars had been in the hands of Pennsylvania’s treasurer over the past three years, the state could be more than $50 million richer today. Had we invested as California did, that figure could jump to almost $100 million. And had the tax money been in an investment arrangement like Florida’s, it might have earned more than $140 million more than it did in the hands of Ohio Treasurer Joseph Deters.

Of course, every state handles short-term investment of its tax dollars differently. And Ohio investment policy is known to be among the more restrictive in the country. Still, it is difficult to find a comparable group of short- term investments whose returns from 1999 to 2001 were less impressive.

A Plain Dealer analysis found that the rate of return on Ohio’s $6.9 billion portfolio underperformed an array of its low-risk counterparts: treasury funds of neighboring states, treasury funds of similar-size states and the treasuries of Ohio’s four biggest counties.” [Plain Dealer, 9/6/2002]

Yep, Borges was at the heart of a public corruption case that it cost Ohioans millions in bad investments.

In May of last year, when The Other Paper reported on Borges’ conviction and his role in Kasich’s gubernatorial campaign kickoff, the Kasich campaign relegated Borges’ to the role of nothing more than a “campaign volunteer:”

Not to be deterred from public service, the recently unveiled Kasich for Governor campaign confirmed that Borges was enlisted to help Republican candidate defeat Ted Strickland in the 2010 gubernatorial race. “He was a volunteer for our kickoff rally June 1. He was not paid for it,” said Rob Nichols, a spokesman for the Kasich campaign, about Borges. “There were a lot of moving parts at this event. He helped make for a very good evening. We appreciated his help.” [The Other Paper 6/17/2009]

In September 2009, Borges was able to get the judge he appeared in 2004 to expunge and seal his record.  He filed the application on May 11, 2009, just weeks before Kasich was set to announce his official candidacy for Governor.

And now, a guy who was at the center of a public corruption case between Lehman Brothers, government contracts, and campaign donations… is in charge of soliciting donations for Governor-elect Kasich’s inaugural committee.

Again, what could POSSIBLY go wrong?

It’s a New Day, New Way!

  • I thought this was a place we learned to look beyond convictions?

  • Anonymous

    Snark aside. Even in states and cities that have ex-offender statutes, they all have an exception that allows a potential employer to still deny employment if the conviction is relevant to work. So if you have a theft conviction, you can’t have a job where you handle money.

    We’re all for ex-offenders finding work, but it’s pretty jaw dropping to see one right back in the same game so soon that lead to their conviction.

  • oh. i see what you did there. heh.

    you obviously haven’t done enough homework. you miss the whole kasich fake steelworker argument here? go back and look and try harder next time.

  • I think I did miss that argument, because I’m not sure what you’re saying.

  • I was just trying to play devil’s advocate because I generally embrace what you guys say about moving on, and that when you bring up someone’s name, it’s cliche and lazy to bring up their conviction. Especially when others are saying he or she has changed, etc. etc.

    That’s what newspapers are for!

    Maybe a decade should pass first?

  • The gist of it is basically what Modern has said. It’s not quite as simple as your comment makes it. There is a big difference in redemption and putting the fox back in the hen house. You look beyond convictions of abuse of power at your own risk when those who were guilty of abusing power are put back into power.

    Does Borges have a right to get on with his life? Sure. Do we have a duty to be skeptical of him abusing power again and reporting on it? Of course we do. As do you.

  • For reference: http://www.plunderbund.com/2010/10/08/more-on-ex-offenders-fake-steelworker-dude/#comments

    Note: I didn’t actually Edit your original comment. Just hit the wrong button and Disqus automatically tosses in that note. 😉

  • Yeah. You’ll note i was firmly on the side of letting the actor/steelworker/whatever dude move on without being used as a pawn to attack Kasich. I think there is a big difference in that and someone who appears to be plugging themselves back into the same power structures that they abused last time.

    Big difference.

  • The Culture of Corruption Strikes Back #alternateposttitles

  • PS: Bring back DJWorcestershire!

  • Pingback: [UPDATE:] Kasich announced Franklin County GOP Chairman Doug Preisse to Inauguration Committee()

  • JohnLocke

    Let’s look at Penny Pritzker, who was on President Obama’s inaugural committee. She was a director and owner of Summit bank which she personally managed and went bankrupt. Where was your outrage then? Any stories on your blog about the Summit Banker who cost tax payers millions? Kasich’s Executive director pled guilty to a misdemeanor offense after a 14 month investigation according to the story you linked to on your site. You loose any moral authority when you have two sets of rules. The bankers who are democrats that actually make the decisions that blow up a bank get a pass, and a guy who happened to be employed by a bank and had nothing to do with the business unit that brought down the firm gets hammered. Hypocrisy, hypocrisy hypocrisy.

  • Anonymous

    How is a business that went bankrupt the moral equivalent of a person who committed public corruption crimes just six years ago?

  • Pingback: John Kasich still hasn’t found 500 people who want to go to a free, open bar event for his inauguration()

  • Pingback: Matt Borges at intersection of scandal between prominent law firm and Kasich inaugural committee()

Looking for something?

Use the form below to search the site:

Still not finding what you're looking for? Drop a comment on a post or contact us so we can take care of it!