It’s not often that the U.S. Senate’s arcane rules of operation can have a direct impact on saving lives now and into the future. But that’s exactly what will happen on what Senate Parliamentarian Elizabeth MacDonough determined Republicans can and cannot do when it comes to trying to pass their worse version of the House’s already bad bill to repeal the Affordable Care Act, otherwise known as Obamacare.
As reported by Kaiser Health News, MacDonough has made a determination that certain provisions of the Republican ‘Better Care Reconciliation Act‘ released on June 26, 2017, violate the Byrd Rule. Under the Byrd rule, the Senate is “prohibited from considering extraneous matter as part of a reconciliation bill or resolution or conference report thereon.” Moreover, it “may be invoked only against reconciliation bills, amendments thereto, and reconciliation conference reports.”
For political addicts and those who don’t understand the difference between passing a bill by simple majority, called reconciliation, or by a super-majority of 60 votes out of 100, it means that Democrats have Republicans over a procedural barrel on many important sections of the bad bill they can’t wiggle out of.
Byrd Is The Word
Should the Senate proceed to the bill this week, as Majority Leader Mitch McConnell of Kentucky claims he will do, a not insignificant number of provisions in the bad bill “may be struck from the legislation absent 60 votes.”
According to a written document called “Background on the Byrd Rule Decisions,” assembled by the Senate Budget Committee Minority Staff, the significance of the Senate parliamentarian’s determinations is that 17 sections cannot be approved without meeting the 60-vote threshold, as non budgetary issues require.
MacDonough advised that “abortion restrictions on the premium tax credit and the small business tax credit, and the language defunding Planned Parenthood” violate the Byrd Rule, named for long-time but now deceased West Virginia U.S. Senator Robert Byrd, that prohibit the Senate from “considering extraneous matter as part of a reconciliation bill or resolution or conference report thereon.”
The “Buffalo Bailout,” which was used to secure votes in the U.S. House, has also been found by parliamentarian Macdonough to violate the Byrd Rule, threatening other state-specific buy-offs.
Boosting Dems Chances To Kill GOP Health Care Bill
Provisions in the GOP bill subject to a 60-vote Byrd Rule Point of Order:
• Defunding Planned Parenthood: This section prohibits Planned Parenthood from receiving Medicaid funds for one year. (Sec. 124)
• Abortion Restrictions for Tax Credits: Two separate provisions contain Hyde Amendment language to prevent premium tax credits and small business tax credits from being used to purchase health insurance that covers abortion. (Sec. 102(d)(1) and Sec. 103(b))
• Sunset of Essential Health Benefits Requirement for Medicaid: This provision states that, beginning in 2020, states no longer have to cover essential health benefits in their Medicaid
alternative benefit plans. (Sec. 126(b))
• Funding for Cost-Sharing Subsidies: This section replicates current law by providing funding for the subsidies through 2019. (Sec. 208)
• Stabilizing the Individual Insurance Markets (“Six Month Lock Out”): This section imposes a six-month waiting period for individuals attempting to enroll in coverage in the
individual market who cannot demonstrate that they have maintained continuous coverage.(Sec. 206)
• Medical Loss Ratio: This section allows states to determine how much insurers are allowed to spend on administration, marketing, and profits versus health care. (Sec. 205)
• Availability of Rollover Funds: This provision allows states that spend less than their targeted block grant amount to rollover funds to the following year and to use funds for non-
health purposes, specifically repealing the provision of the Social Security Act that prohibits states from using Medicaid funds to build roads, bridges, and stadiums. (Sec. 134 –
1903B(c)(2)(D)) (Note: this provision has been removed from the most recent draft).
• Decrease in Target Expenditures for Required Expenditures by Certain Political Subdivisions (“Buffalo Bailout”): This provision limits the ability of New York State to require counties other than New York City to contribute funding to the state’s Medicaid program. (Sec. 133 – 1903(c)(4))
• Grandfathering Certain Medicaid Waivers; Prioritization of HCBS Waivers: This section says that the Secretary will encourage states to adopt Medicaid Home and Community Based Services (HCBS) waivers but does not set forth any actual details for this plan. (Sec. 136)
• Reporting of CMS-64 Data (T-MSIS): This provision requires the Secretary of HHS to submit a report on Congress recommending whether expenditure data from the Transformed Medicaid Statistical Information System (T-MSIS) is preferable to data from state CMS-64 reports for making certain Medicaid decisions. (Sec. 133 – 1903(h)(5))
• Coordination with States: This section requires the Secretary to consult with states before finalizing Medicaid rules. (Sec. 137) Provisions Not Subject to a 60-vote Byrd Rule Point of Order
• Medicaid Work Requirements: This provision allows states the option to impose work requirements on Medicaid enrollees who are nondisabled, nonelderly, and nonpregnant. Pregnant women are exempt from any work requirements for 60 days after giving birth. (Sec.131)
• Providing Safety Net Funding for Non-Expansion States: – This section provides $10 billion for non-expansion states. (Sec. 129)
• State Stability and Innovation Fund: This section includes abortion restrictions on funding for the State Stability and Innovation Fund by tacking the Fund onto the CHIP program.
• Equity Adjustment: This provision provides for adjusting the per capita cap targets of low-and high-spending states to promote equity. (Sec. 133 – 1903(c)(5))
• Repeal of Cost-Sharing Subsidy Program: This section permanently repeals cost-sharing subsidies beginning in 2020. (Sec. 209)
• Reporting of CMS-64 Data: This provision requires states to include information on per capita cap enrollment and expenditures, psychiatric hospital expenditures, and children with
complex medical conditions in their Medicaid expenditure reports. (Sec. 133 — 1903(h)(1))
Still Under Review
• Waivers for State Innovation (Essential Health Benefits): This section amends Sec. 1332 of the ACA to allow states to waive age rating, essential health benefits, and pre-existing
condition requirements so long as their proposal does not increase the federal deficit. (Sec.207)
• Small Business Health Plans: This section would allow small businesses to establish “association health plans” that could be sold across state lines. For regulatory purposes, these
plans would be treated as part of the large group market and thus would be exempt from many ACA requirements such as covering essential health benefits. (Sec. 139)
• Change in Permissible Age Variation in Health Insurance Premium Rates (“Age Tax”): This section allows insurers to charge older Americans at least five times more than what they charge younger individuals. (Sec. 204)
• Flexible Block Grant Option for States: This section allows states the option to receive a lump sum Medicaid “block grant” instead of the per capita cap payments. (Sec. 134)
Democrats can’t cheer all the determinations made by the Senate parliamentarian, though. MacDonough helped Republicans, too, finding “that only a simple majority is needed for language allowing states to impose work requirements for Medicaid recipients.”
She also said, according to KHN, that a provision that will ban abortions “if the services are paid through a new fund provided to states would be allowed,” because that fund will be governed by existing rules that already ban abortion in most cases.
Media on Monday was absorbed with the appearance of Donald Trump’s son-in-law Jared Kushner’s before a Senate Committee probing deeper into allegations of collusion between the Trump campaign and Russian agents.
Clearly, Senate Parliamentarian Elizabeth MacDonough has thrown a barricade Senate Republicans cannot surmount without plunging the chamber into chaos. The attempt to kill Obamacare, or as the president likes to say, “let it fail,” won’t be as easy to repeal as Leader McConnell had envisioned.
MacDonough’s determinations, it’s not a stretch to say, will indeed save lives by enabling Obamacare to live on as GOP arsonists realize they can’t burn the house down with just 50 votes, then relying on Vice President Mike Pence to be winning 51st vote.
No related stories.