In view of Plain Dealer news room’s mission to report the news, the absence of news about the people who are supposed to report the news of others has left the staff in a state of day-to-day suspended animation.  And hardly feeling secure in their line of work.

The problem, of course, is the presumed impending doom of the state’s biggest and often most puzzling newspaper (as we now know it), a deeply ensconced establishment journal that has tight-roped for years through local issues in a diverse city that has needed little encouragement to become unruly.

Ever since the word got out last year that the PD’s absentee owners were serious about slicing another third of the paper’s news staff (58 from about 165 is the operative number) and had a track record of  reducing publication to thrice-weekly in other cities, it was only natural for reporters and on-site editors to wonder about their own survival.    You still won’t get an answer  to the fate of the yet-to-be named outcasts. The hit list won’t be known, we were told by staff sources, until May.

Nobody is more frustrated by the current lull in the action than Harlan Spector, the Guild president who  has sat  through  meetings with the brass that recently ended with still more union concessions and few specifics about the layoffs. In a way, the Guild faced the option of death by hanging or firing squad.

“I’d love to know what they’re planning,” Spector  said when I called him a few days ago.  The “they” in this instance is Advance Publications owned by the Newhouse family.   The company has already revealed its  course with other papers in its grasp with  something called the Michigan model.  It started with the conversion in 2009 of the Ann Arbor News from print to digital.  Along the way, the owners squeezed such papers  as the New Orleans Times-Picayune into a three-day-a-week  format. That seems to be where the PD is headed, if the speculation rules the reality. Some time in the spring, the PD’s readers could be getting the paper on Wednesday, Friday and Sunday – if the current subscribers decide they want it at all.

Again, Spector and others on the staff with  whom I spoke can do no more than rely on Advance’s past actions.  Besides, they suspiciously noted that Editor Debra Simmons and Managing Editor Thom Fladung just visited New Orleans when the  Mardi Gras was only a memory.

“Everybody’s on edge,” veteran reporter told me.  “There are no decisions being made here – it’s all being handled by the (Advance) New York office where the guys are preparing to do it (expletives deleted).”

The talk now is that the paper will see the rise of “curators”  – a post -journalism term about the folks who will post news on the Internet.  I’m not at all familiar with the precise process and will leave it at that.  However, it has been evident for some time with the challenge of digital news that newspaper owners almost never inject the word “journalism” into their outlooks.  It’s become a meaningless distraction to the business model and therefore undefinable in today’s alternate communications universe.

Journalism as it was once known didn’t disappear overnight.  Instead it was painfully debilitated in recent years by the space-time speed of electronic transmission in the palms of a new generation’s hands.

Still, during the print media’s slow trek to the graveyard, it would be nice to meet somebody high up in the business slip  in a nod to journalism just so we have a hint of what nobody on Wall Street seems to be talking about anymore.

  • dmoore2222

    Unfortunately, the same kind of shakeout happened in the printing undustry when desktop publishing programs became available. Pesonally, I love having a newpaper in hand and the ritual that comes with it. I can remember when the Beacon Journal was doing superb reporting on just about everything. A Saturday or Sunday without a newspaper was like a death in the family. But the Dispatch is such a disaster I don’t subscribe to it anymore. It’s probably what’s happening in a lot of industries–the good people are leaving and bottom feeders are all that’s left.The millenials don’t seem to have any preference for hard copy anything. It’s probably just a matter of time before newsprint is any more than an exception. It’s a sad ending.

  • greatlaurel

    Warren Buffet is investing in newspapers. He knows there is a
    tremendous market out there for newspapers, if they were run properly,
    He made a point of criticizing newspapers that cut content and are
    reducing days of publishing, My family stopped taking the Logan Daily
    News and the Columbus Dispatch within the last year, because we would no
    longer financially support the appalling right wing propaganda spewed
    in those papers, The vultures that took over the PD and the Beacon
    Journal are incredibly bad business people, with a little imagination
    and investment in content, their newspapers would be the number one
    choice for information. Young people ignore the newspapers due to the
    bad content and horrid websites. I go back to my old standby
    explanation for that type of behavior. Rich people are stupid! (with a
    very few notable exceptions, of course)

    Abe, let your friends
    know that there are many of us who are very concerned about their
    futures. Good luck to them (and to all of us). Most of us are victims
    of shock doctrine economics.

    PS, we always loved the Beacon
    Journal, it flew off the shelves here in southeastern Ohio. We never
    understood why they stopped distributing it down here. There was always
    a race to see who would grab the last one at Kroger’s every morning!

Looking for something?

Use the form below to search the site:

Still not finding what you're looking for? Drop a comment on a post or contact us so we can take care of it!