In a blockbuster report this morning, The New Republic uncovered that the FBI is investigating a slew of campaign donations to our absentee Treasurer Josh Mandel and his congressional buddy Jim Renacci.

News of yet another investigation is truly shocking, even for the likes of Mandel and Renacci, for whom scandals ordinarily constitute another day at the office.

As reported by The Toledo Blade in August of last year, the donations, totaling $100,000 each to Mandel and Renacci, came from just 16 employees of a marketing firm owned by Republican donor Benjamin Suarez, along with six of their spouses. Each made max contributions of $5,000 to the campaign coffers of Mandel, Renacci or both Republicans seeking reelection. In total, some couples donated as much as $20,000.

Here’s the kicker: many of the donors appear to have lacked the financial means with which to make such enormous contributions. Others didn’t have the donor histories you would expect from contributors suddenly maxing out to campaigns

Alec MacGillis at The New Republic confirms this morning that the FBI has launched an investigation into the donations to Mandel and Renacci:

“The owner of our company is very Republican,” [Charles Stewart, the director of merchandising at Suarez] said. But, he added, “He doesn’t push the executives to give.” Then he said something that piqued my interest: “There was an investigation. I wasn’t involved in it, because I didn’t give the amount of money [others] gave.” The woman tugged on his arm, urging him to shut up. He apologized, saying he had to go and that his mind was a bit jet-lagged. …

It gets worse:

 I visited the home of Michael Blubaugh, a copywriter at Suarez who had given $5,000 each to Renacci and Mandel last year—and whose wife, Donna, had done the same. They live in a modest subdivision, in a home valued by Zillow at about $142,000,

Last year, Renacci shrugged off any allegations of wrongdoing regarding the Suarez donations, despite the fact that Suaraz employees were suddenly his top donors, according to, moving up from number nine on the list, with a single donation of $10,000 in 2010, to number one this year.

In 2012 Suarez employees contributed even more money than the employees of Timken, the company that had previously been the largest donor for Renacci. Timken was considered so important that John Boehner personally helped redraw Renacci’s congressional district so the company’s headquarters would still fall into Renacci’s district.

Meanwhile, Josh Mandel bizarrely declared he was “proud” of the donations he received, as evidenced by the thank-you notes he writes them (uhh… what?).

Watch Josh Mandel’s awkward answer on his questionable contributions here…

In light of the FBI’s investigation, I wonder: When will the next shoe drop?

Josh Mandel and Jim Renacci have already demonstrated there are no barriers to what they’ll do for a quick buck. Between throwing their next fundraisers in places like the Bahamas and Key Largo, Josh Mandel and Jim Renacci ought to come clean by immediately revealing to Ohioans everything they know about these tainted donations.

  • annekarima53

    You caught the nervous tick – right?  Dangerous times ahead.

  • stryx

    “many of the donors appear to have lacked the financial means with which to make such enormous contributions. ”

    Oh my.

    I seem to remember another scandal in Ohio where a highroller used straw donors to stuff money into a politician’s campaign.

    “Theodore Wasky, special agent in charge of the Cleveland FBI office,
    said as many as 40 agents worked the case over the past year.

    He said other aspects of the investigation are continuing and issued a
    stern warning to people who may have information regarding the Noe

    I would encourage anyone with information to get on the train.

    Either you’re on the train or you are on the tracks, and the train is coming down those tracks, Mr. Wasky said.”

  • Xx

     I hope that nervous tick shows up in some commercials.

  • Ranacci is a crook and Mandel a idiot!!!!

  • Retrofuturistic

    Obviously, the entire Kasich administration is corrupt.

  • Has anyone else noticed that Josh Mandel doesn’t know exactly how much money is in the Ohio pension fund?  The Ohio Capital Blog caught his mistake (

  • Spitfiremk1

    Would that be anything like the ACME model that Wile E. Coyote buys, cause I sure would like to see both of them wave “bye-bye” as they ride the plateau down to the canyon floor and become accordion people.

Looking for something?

Use the form below to search the site:

Still not finding what you're looking for? Drop a comment on a post or contact us so we can take care of it!