Back in February, the conventional wisdom of the traditional media was that Senate Bill 5 showed a political reality in Ohio in which organized labor was politically powerless to stop, especially in this budgetary political environment.  (Of course, they said this even after public opinion polling showed Ohioans were already not conceptually supportive of Kasich’s plan to pursue collective bargaining “reform.”)  Sure, they might be able to put it to a referendum, but that was viewed as a jump ball.  Fast forward to the present week.

Months after John Kasich signed the bill, and as expectations grow that the We Are Ohio campaign is going to submit well over 1,000,000 signatures (a record for any petition filed in Ohio), having only sixty some days to collect them, the soft proponents of SB 5 are screaming for a compromise.

Rumors (well sourced ones) spread this week that the Kasich Administration was wanting to divide SB 5 into multiple issues so that their proxy campaign could, in essence, negotiate with voters about which terms in SB 5 they could allow to become law in exchange for voiding others through referenda.

Then, there’s the tripe being spewed by Brent Larkin at the Cleveland Plain Dealer, who is publicly begging John Kasich and the GOP legislative leadership to negotiate some deal with organized labor now.  Now after the GOP portrayed school teachers, police officers, nurses, prison guards, firefighters and other hard-working public sector employees as nothing more than “idiot” parasites causing all of Ohio’s budgetary ills.  After they railroaded it through by last minute committee changes and countless secret meetings to work out its terms.  After hundreds of witnesses who testified in opposition were ignored and the GOP rammed through whatever they could given the votes they could get from their own caucus, the Brent Larkins of the world now want to lay the groundwork to blame the unions for not compromising in their counterpunch.

There is one individual, and only one individual, who is responsible for SB 5’s likely repeal and the all-or-nothing battle being waged through Election Day now.  Only six months into his term, and John Kasich has provided Ohio with failed leadership.  He could have spent the transition meeting with both the leadership of organized labor and local government leaders to try and reach a bargain.  Sure, he probably would not have been successful in finding something organized labor could live with, but he could still created a “tool” that local governments want.  Instead, he’s created a “tool” drafted by the Imagineers of out-0f-State, out-0f-touch ideologically myopic organizations like Americans for Prosperity.  It’s a tool that is celebrated by conservative ideologues, but it is more ceremonial than utilitarian.

Kasich decided that instead of being a leader who tried to build SB 5 on consensus, he’d adopt a “take no prisoners,” blindly partisan approach.  He didn’t have to listen to organized labor, he reckoned, what with the large Republican and unprecedented  conservative majorities in the General Assembly.  And the Brent Larkins of the Ohio media world wrote columns largely agreeing with him at the time.

Now the “We Are Ohio” campaign is ready to delivery over 1,000,000 signatures from Ohioans who say they believe the legislature got it wrong on the bill, and SB 5 should be put to a vote to repeal, the Brent Larkins of the world realize that Bill Seitz was right all along.  All Governor Kasich has managed to do is provoke a sleeping political giant and outraged it so much that they are now in danger of creating a powerful political precedent that could render collective bargaining “reform” into a third rail of Ohio politics for at least a generation. 

The plan to subdivide SB 5 at the ballot and Mr. Larkin’s fruitless prayer that somehow John Kasich a) will come to the bargaining table, and b) hasn’t empowered organized labor so much that he still has the political leverage to get what he wants from such negotiations all are implicit acknowledgements that even the proponents of SB 5 realize that John Kasich has failed as a leader.  After all, such plots are nothing more than the fevered hope that somehow the damage caused by Kasich’s failed leadership can be mitigated, that somehow, something they support in SB 5 can survive.

In begging for compromise of a bill the Governor has already signed, Larkin pleaded:

But there are also many thoughtful people on both sides of this issue. It’s time for them to push aside those who view Senate Bill 5 through a purely political prism and to explore the possibility of a compromise.

The problem is that pushing aside those who view Senate Bill 5 through a purely political prism means pushing aside Governor John Kasich and the GOP legislative leadership that passed SB 5.  Larkin’s problem is that his mythical negotiators would have to be people who have no political power to get Kasich, Niehaus, and Batchelder to go along, so it would be a compromise with no means to make it a reality.  SB 5 and the Kasich budget were political declarations of war with organized labor, now that the war is in earnest, Mr. Larkin futilely suggests now is the time to send in the… the diplomats?

Larkin ignores that Kasich has painted himself into a political corner.  His base wouldn’t tolerate seeing him now negotiate with labor after he has ready them for an all-out political war in Ohio.  And with 1,000,000 signatures and public opinion on their side, organized labor hardly has much to motivate them to come to the bargaining table, either.  Kasich is powerless to move himself into any other direction other than hope SB 5 can survive the will of the voters come November 8, 2011.

It’s not like Brent Larkin should be surprised that Kasich would be a failed, ideologically myopic leader:

His Republican challenger, John Kasich, is a former congressman from suburban Columbus given to Reagan-style optimism and bold, sometimes questionable, ideas. He is just as clearly the wild card, eager to shake up the status quo and even challenge his own party, but also capable of talking himself right off a cliff.

Does he understand that being a Fox News provocateur is not the same as being the leader of a diverse, complex state?

[Source: Cleveland Plain Dealer, “The Plain Dealer endorses John Kasich for governor of Ohio” (Oct. 3, 2010)]

Senate Bill 5, and how Kasich railroaded it through the legislature, is precisely when Kasich talked “himself right off a cliff”  as only a Fox News provocateur could do so proudly.  There are certain decisions you make in life, Mr. Larkin, that you can’t bargain your way out of.  You either atone for your mistakes and spend your remaining time acknowledging the error of your ways, or you steel yourself in abundant confidence that you made the right decision no matter how fatalistic your choice actually appears.

You lie in bed with dogs, you can expect to get fleas, Mr. Larkin.  If you wanted someone who could deal with contentious issues by developing bipartisan consensus, we already had that in Governor Strickland.  Your paper (and you) wanted Governor Kasich, you got it.  Live with it.  Own it.

It’s 136 days until SB 5 detonates on Election Day.  You might as well just wave your little hat and scream like a cowboy all the way down.  It’s just as productive as wishing for a political compromise John Kasich is utterly unwilling and unable to deliver.

  • Some great political blunders:

    Japan bombs Pearl Harbor, brings the sleeping giant into WWII against the Axis alliance.In 1963, the civil rights movement was flagging, and along came Alabama’s Bull Conner to give it high visibility.It looks as if Kasich’s SB5 can be added to that list…

  • Sluggo

    Brent Larkin = concern troll. 
    Bonus points for the Major Kong reference. “Waaa hoooo!”

  • Annekarima

    Hmmm…just read this somewhere…”what are the rules of the enemy?  Do not underestimate them.”

  • Bob

    Very nice, Mods. Well written and clear. But the slime from the other side is being stored up right now and those 136 days are going to be brutal.

  • Joe

    Larkin comes across as smarmy and disingenuous. Kasichophants just get lamer by the day. 

  • Anastasjoy

    Northeast Ohio is not “eating itself.” Many of the local Democrats ARE organized labor, and so the party hasn’t “turned on” organized labor, despite Mayor Frank Jackson’s bizarre support of Kasich’s attack on teachers this week while turning around and saying he still supports repealing SB 5.  The Plain Dealer was NOT the only large paper to endorse Kasich — all three of the state’s largest papers did (Columbus Dispatch and Cincinnati Inquirer). I agree though that the Plain Dealer has completely lost touch with the market and people are abandoning it in droves because it has no relevance to them.

  • Anastasjoy

    Northeast Ohio is not “eating itself.” Many of the local Democrats ARE organized labor, and so the party hasn’t “turned on” organized labor, despite Mayor Frank Jackson’s bizarre support of Kasich’s attack on teachers this week while turning around and saying he still supports repealing SB 5.  The Plain Dealer was NOT the only large paper to endorse Kasich — all three of the state’s largest papers did (Columbus Dispatch and Cincinnati Inquirer). I agree though that the Plain Dealer has completely lost touch with the market and people are abandoning it in droves because it has no relevance to them.

  • Anastasjoy

    Concern troll is exactly right. Larkin thinks there are “thoughtful people” on “both sides”? The side of unilaterally imposing job- and economy-destroying conditions on valuable public sector workers against their will and those in favor of not doing so? That is laughable. That “both sides” crap is, well, crap. No “thoughtful” person could possibly think that Kasich’s ideologically extremist positions, pushed with bully boy tactics completely deaf to alternative ideas and opposing opinions, is reasonable.

    As Modern pointed out, in quoting from the editorial I also frequently refer to, the Plainly Republican (Plain Dealer) extolled Kasich’s brash, steamroller approach and damned Ted Strickland for his steady, pragmatic approach, calling him boring. I reiterate the offer I made at Ohio Daily Blog: if anyone can guess the exact number of signatures gathered to repeal SB 5, I will send them a lovely picture of Ted Strickland suitable for framing and gazing at while imagining he is still governor, none of this divisive crap is happening, and the state’s economic recovery is continuing without dark clouds on the horizon.

  • Fotogirlcb2002

    SB5 will go down but what does it really mean? Yes ,there were and are more against the passing of this bill than any of them anticipated. In all actuallity there are bills that have simular stuff in them like sb5 does.( hb 153 addresses a lot of school and teacher issues like is in sb5  amoung other topics) These people sit up nites figuring how they can get this stuff through and with other states getting these issues through like NJ and Wisconsin they will try more tactics.
    Its so hard for me to believe that these folks dont care any more for the people of Ohio than they do. Its hard for me to believe that people think Kasich is doing a good job–but then not much of this has taken effect yet. When the cuts hit home either with them or elderly parents things will be looked at differently. 
    I am waiting for the whinning to all start when they are bombarted with tax leveies every election.
    Taxpayers have no clue what hes really doing that they pay for. Hes not doing a thing for smaller govt. the heads of agencies have more assistants than before all making top dollar. They are also being allowed to drive state vehicles back and forth to work using state gas and getting oil changes that the state pays for. Now they think they need new cars and trucks for such reasons. Its an outrage, yet you hear nothing about this.  

  • Blandser77

    just like the new money saving prison reform bill, the larger cities and counties are going to be tasked to pay for all these alternative prison ideas they have heaped upon us, not to mention pay the price of light sentences for “non violent” crimes like thieves, burglars and addicts.

  • the budget bill, all the lies  now they r introducing an minimum wage bill to make min wage obsolete? The sleepn giant is waking up n people r seeing everything now…ive had so many people apologize, n sign the petition..theyve been watchn n now realize they r being led to the slaughter…the gun bills etc..corp breaks..no jobs still…giants wide awake

  • in NOVEMBER ALWAYS REMEMBER TO VOTE THEM OUT 4EVER

  • ARROGANT, N CONTRADICTS  what he says regardn state/teacdhers/fire/po po///then his actions r completely opposite with corp owned private for profit schools..2percent ayp..n hes pourn millions..ohh n no entity can govern them..n no penalties or merrit pay..they have to produce..brennan..he wrote that part of bufget bill..millions of taxpayer dollars to an inapprop school..for profit..more tax dollars gone…at kasichs n 4 his buds at our expense

  • we no but the people seethe lies now..n now theyr attackn min wage.,.,

  • i wont but there paper, nor the disgraces, nor any thing from walmart target n any affiliation of kasucks contributors n crew…ill buy off a small business person, union or supporter of unions..otherwise..forget it..n in nov..vote these thieves n sell outs out

  • Anonymous

    You want to talk about Kasich and his base?  His base is leaving – in the process of gathering petition signatures, I and many of my fellow volunteers all have stories from people who have declared they will never vote Republican again.  These teachers, firefighters, police, and other state workers, will never again trust the word of a Republican governor.  Kasich won by less than 70,000 votes.  There are a million people who will never take the chance of getting screwed again.  They may not all vote Democratic, but they certainly will never vote Republican.

  • Hungry Coyote

    When I read Larkin’s opinion column in the PD I was flabbergasted. These people have no shame. How can any of the idiots who supported and railroaded this bill through the legislature look any Ohioan in the eye. I guess they didn’t hear the thousands of people inside or outside the capitol building, nor the calls to compromise. Now they are going to paint the state workers and unions as unwilling to compromise? I also see this as another colossal failure of leadership by Kasich and the republican controlled legislature. These people were elected to serve the citizens of Ohio, not cow tow to the Chamber of Congress and The Koch brothers “Americans for Prosperity”.

  • Anonymous

    King John not only created a tool, he IS a tool.  Brent Larkin is a tool, also.

Looking for something?

Use the form below to search the site:


Still not finding what you're looking for? Drop a comment on a post or contact us so we can take care of it!